After a Year of Bad Films, Finally There’s a Movie Worth Seeing: Song Sung Blue

By Jan Wahl—

Let there be light.

Hamnet, Wicked, Kiss of the Spider Woman, Nuremberg, Marty Supreme … how many bad movies can they make or remake? We just went through a year of bad films. Now there is good news to begin the year: Song Sung Blue is a supreme example of why and how a movie works. Everything from casting to music, and from sets to plot, knocks it out of the park. If only mainstream Hollywood would pay attention; this is how you make a movie.

It all begins with Hugh Jackman. From his first close-up to his last fade-out, he creates a character of charisma, drama, eccentricity, and humor. I admit to being a major fan and a camp follower of Mr. Jackman, having seen him on stage, in one-man shows, and in musicals. But this is the most remarkable film performance of his that I have seen; every moment carries the gravitas of a man in love with music and a woman. It irks me that Jackman often doesn’t get the credit he deserves, and I am hoping that he receives an Oscar for this performance.

Kate Hudson reaches Jackman’s level of brilliance. Both leading players sing their own songs. It is easy to root for them both; I haven’t been so engrossed in a movie in a couple of years.

The film is based on the true story of a Milwaukee couple that perform as a Neil Diamond tribute band. We follow them into the highs and lows of their lives and regional fame. Apparently, their story is detailed in a 2008 documentary of the same name, Song Sung Blue. That’s the next one on my list.

• 

• 

There is no way you should miss this film. It’s a single, strong narrative with a ridiculously talented leading man. If the Academy doesn’t recognize him, it is due to show business’ jealousy. I have been guilty myself of saying that we do not have stars today along the lines of Gable, Tracy, Power, or Flynn. Roll them all up and you’ve got Hugh Jackman. Sorry to gush, but ask me about him and I will do it again.

Jan Wahl is a Hollywood historian and film critic on various broadcast outlets. She has two Emmys and many awards for her longtime work on behalf of film.

Off the Wahl
Published on January 15, 2026